Should Healthcare Run More Like Airlines?

While most people dread flying during the holidays, it’s hard to ignore how efficiently the airlines are able to move millions of people across the country.  While we tend to dramatize issues with flying, today I want to appreciate the tremendous job the industry has done to create an effective (and dare I say friendly?) member experience that healthcare could learn from.

Flight Purchasing

How The Airlines Do It: How do you like to buy plane tickets?  Some people use a travel agent, some people call the airline, others buy online (either directly from the airline or from flight comparison websites).  Airlines give customers several channels to buy tickets by creating their own infrastructure, but also opening up their data for other companies to use.  Freeing up their data also creates price transparency, leading to greater competition and lower prices.  While everybody hates the new fees airlines tack on, decoupling extras (e.g., checked luggage) can also lower costs or keep them steady since only the people who use these services are paying for them.  Finally, customers can also get lower prices through group buying, using companies like Egencia that exchange volume for price.

What Healthcare Can Learn: Right now, you have very few choices about how you can pay for healthcare – given the high cost, insurance is the only route for most people, and that’s often tied to your employer.  This may change with the individual exchanges, as employers may drop coverage and folks will get to choose which plan is best.  As a result, insurance companies will need to create more customer-friendly plans and interfaces to help customers understand their choices in a much more competitive market. 

While healthcare is mostly fee-for-service (i.e., you’re only charged for what you use), there remains a lack of price transparency – do you know how much your x-ray costs?  While new startups have emerged to address this (e.g., Change Health, Healthcare BlueBook), we need to continue to create easier tools and better incentives for people make the right treatment decisions.  Finally, group buying has existed in groups such as Pharmacy Benefit Managers, but newer incentive-based models (e.g., ACOs) have the opportunity to be scaled up.

Pre-Flight Experience

How The Airlines Do It: Airlines have embraced technology to make the pre-flight experience better.  First, airlines use code sharing agreements to fill less crowded flights on other airlines or transfer frequent flyer points across multiple carriers, completely blind to the customer.  Second, airlines have embraced newer consumer technologies – for example, United and American are two of the first businesses to work closely with Apple to integrate their apps with their mobile payment service, Passbook.  Finally, security, one of the most important parts of the operation, is handled by a centralized agency, the Transportation Security Administration, meaning airlines can focus on what they’re good at rather than the complexities of security.

What Healthcare Can Learn: The code sharing agreements are akin to hospitals and doctors seamlessly transmitting patient information across systems.  While hospital systems do this today, it needs to be more portable and touch more patients, possibly through larger alliances that cover more health systems using the same technology.  I also like how airlines are working closely with mobile companies on cutting edge consumer technology – major health systems may benefit from tighter alliances with those major tech companies.  Finally, ceding certain activities to a single group takes healthcare companies out of what their bad at (e.g., data management).  EHRs may be a good example – does it make sense for the industry to name a single standard, and then allow health systems to outsource the work to dedicated vendors?

In-Flight Experience

How The Airlines Do It: Sure, the seats are cramped and the food is mediocre (when there’s food at all), but airlines have done some things right.  First, any in-flight purchases are cash-free, limiting the payment options, but simplifying the process to make things more efficient.  Next, airlines have created partnerships with movie and television studios to present current entertainment options or started handing out tablets to personalize the experience.  Finally, frequent flyers are often rewarded in-flight through a variety of special perks (e.g., free checked bags, automatic upgrades).

What Healthcare Can Learn: Efficiencies gained through limited payment systems would be a clear benefit to healthcare (i.e., eliminating the complexities of the fragmented insurance system means less admin headaches for providers).  The entertainment partnerships are vaguely similar to ACO’s, where there’s an incentive to produce and deliver high quality products – in this case, the airline benefits from having an engaged, happy flyers, and the studios have a captive audience to pitch their best shows.  Finally, I’ve written about “frequent flyer” healthcare programs in the past – integrating something like this into a hospital system could be an effective way to gain loyalty with select consumer segments.

These are certainly pipedreams with a multitude of complexities and challenges, but after flying this past week, I’ve come to appreciate what the airlines have done in the face of tremendous challenges and I’m hopeful healthcare can do the same.