Can Shock and Awe Tactics Work For Healthcare?

One of the highlights of my Chicago summer is the Air and Water Show.  Every year, the city brings out stunt planes and jets to put on a big spectacle along the lake.  Regardless of whether I’m at North Beach or sitting in my apartment, I feel like I’m part of the action if for no other reason than the sound of these planes invading our city.

Listening to the jets in my apartment this year reminded me of the early tactics of the Iraq War.  At the beginning of the conflict, the US flew these same planes overhead and remotely bombed cities to scare Saddam Hussein and force him to surrender.  This “shock and awe” tactic certainly scared me into paying attention to the show this past weekend – could it do the same for patients?

A great example of this already in place are the cigarette pack labels that either warn smokers about the dangers smoking or show graphic images of its effects.  Another example is the annual drug or drunk driving seminars for middle and high school students, complete with a totaled car for dramatic effect.

But could this tactic be put in place for less severe problems and a more sophisticated group?  Let’s say we want to target heart disease.  While we read stories about it every day, people may benefit by seeing, firsthand, the impact of poor nutrition, low exercise, and not taking medications. 

For example, a company could require all employees to view an annual seminar on the topic, where they bring in a motivational speaker directly affected by the disease to talk about its impact on them and show how the disease has ravaged their life.   To get people to attend, the employer could provide insurance credits or a reward through attendance.  The seminar would be sponsored and facilitated either by the employer or their insurance company, who would both realize cost savings through better behavior.  At the end of the day, this type of event could promote better health by exposing realities first hand at a relatively low cost.

The tough part of this analogy, however, is that the tactic didn’t work in Iraq or with cigarettes.  While they both initially opened people’s eyes, these sounds and images became too commonplace, so people made it part of their daily routines and started to ignore them.  That’s why I think the key is limiting this type of marketing and making it as shocking and controversial as possible.  This solution would also need to be part of a larger effort that rewarded behavior rather than just scaring, but it could send a strong message like jet engines in Chicago each summer.